Uploaded image for project: 'translate5'
  1. translate5
  2. TRANSLATE-1440

XLF Short tag view does not accurately reflect tag order and relationship between tags

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • translate5 - 3.0.0
    • None
    • Editor general

    • XLIFF export from Across v6.3 12117

      In the short tag view placeable elements in the target text are consecutively numbered independently from placeable numbering in the source text.

      This leads to the same placeable having different numbers in source and target text in the following two cases:

      1. If the order of placeables has been changed during translation. (Indicated by the red arrows in the attached screenshot)
      2. If a non-breaking space or another character that is treated as a placeable is inserted in the translation. (Indicated by the blue boxes in the screenshot)

      The screenshot shows the same segment in full tag view and short tag view.

      Apparently this has already been fixed once before (TRANSLATE-957), so this error likely due to the structure of xliff files created by Across.

      The ph Tags in Across XLF files do contain an id attribute to which the numbering could be mapped.

      Additional small issue:

      Duplicating tags inside the edited target does not trigger the tag check anymore (only missing tags so far).

        1. example.zip
          1 kB
        2. screenshot.jpg
          screenshot.jpg
          187 kB

          [TRANSLATE-1440] XLF Short tag view does not accurately reflect tag order and relationship between tags

          Thomas Lauria added a comment - - edited

          marcmittag
          What is with SDLXLIFF / CSV / Transit Import?

          For SDLXLIFF its checked, here the same bug persists. CSV and Transit Import are not checked, but I assume that this is the same here.

          Thomas Lauria added a comment - - edited marcmittag What is with SDLXLIFF / CSV / Transit Import? For SDLXLIFF its checked, here the same bug persists. CSV and Transit Import are not checked, but I assume that this is the same here.

          Marc Mittag [Administrator] added a comment -

          Please fix in October 2018

          Marc Mittag [Administrator] added a comment - Please fix in October 2018

            tlauria Thomas Lauria
            transline transline
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: